The Canon EOS and Photography Forums

May be I didn't read well through the forum but I couldn't find the direct comparison of these 2 lenses. Bob has reviewed Tammy and recommended it. Now that the prices are pretty much in the same ball park for both of these lenses, would like to know the pros and cons of each to make a better buying decision. I am planning to buy one of these and as usual a big dilemma about which way to go. Any discussion leading to a decision is appreciated. I currently am using 40D and have no plans for full frame camera any time soon.

Thanks

Subray

The Tamron has several advantages.

First, with the current $100 rebate it's cheaper. The Tamron 60mm f2 macro (http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B00200K9MM/bobatkinsphotogr) is $399 after rebate from Amazon. The Canon sells for $449.

Second it's a full stop faster with an f2.0 maximum aperture vs. the f2.8 of the Canon EF-S 60/2.8 macro  (http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B0007WK8KS/bobatkinsphotogr). For macro work this might give you a slightly brighter viewfinder and possibly better AF accuracy, though since you'll likely be shooting stopped down to get DOF there's no real optical advantage. However if you use the lens for portrait work too (and 60mm f2 makes for a good portrait lens), then you may well shoot it wide open for the smaller DOF and greater background blur.

Third, though it's a crop sensor lens it doesn't use the Canon EF-S mount which means you can mount it on a full frame camera and you can use a TC like the  (http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B000068ODT/bobatkinsphotogrTamron 1.4x) with it to give you an 84/2.8 lens. You can't do either with the Canon EF-S 60mm macro due to the EF-S design mount.

Fourth, the Tamron comes with a 6 year warranty (vs. 1 year for the Canon) and is supplied with a lens hood (with the Canon you have to buy the hood seperately).

I've never tested them side by side and the Canon is a very nice lens, but on balance if I was looking for a 60mm macro for a crop sensor camera, I'd probably go with the Tamron.

Thanks Bob for suggestion. I did place the order for Tammy with Amazon using the link from the forum.

best,

Subray